Shoot… been awhile since I last updated. Totally my bad, got caught up in being in La Paz and then it just felt so daunting to summarize everything that had happened.
So… let’s see, I went to La Paz with the group and got to see the business capital of Bolivia. It’s a dirty, unorganized city, but really very fun and full of interesting restaurants. Plus, I found it easy to get where I needed to go and like everywhere in Bolivia, Bolivians know directions to everywhere.
When we arrived we went right to Tiawanaku, the ruins of the capital of the Andean empire that predates Incans. That was amazing to behold. They were architectural geniuses and incorporated their 13-month calendar throughout the area. Plus, they used the surrounding geography to create perfect straight lines using a complex system of white dots on mountains that I didn’t get at all, but somehow created incredible architecture.
Then, we went to La Paz for the night and stayed in a beautiful hotel. I have to add that I found La Paz challenging to walk with my foot, but thanks to Lupe and Ismael I was given a cane to walk around with. Canes are awesome. I mean I just felt like a boss using it, though I really relied on it a bunch. I feel a little bad because it was inevitably banged up by the trip.
For instance the first night involved a long walk around the city to find a restaurant (which was closed, doh!) and that really took it out of me, but I have to see my foot has greatly improved with the aid of a cane and more rest than I usually would take on trips like this one. (Usually a midday hour or two in bed.) That I hated and am definitely going to do all I can to prevent injuries whenever I travel again.
The next day we met with a Minister of the Foreign Affairs department Fernando Huanacani. He explained the Vivir Bien policy that Bolivia has applied with the new state. The idea is not always getting all you can, but getting what you need, having respect for others and the earth. Really, it sounds great, but it is something we as humans constantly fail to do. If it works here though, I’ll be really happy. My worry is he wanted to spread it to us in the states. Don’t know if that’ll fly.
Then we went and saw the artwork in the studio of Robert Mamani Mamani. He does amazing artwork reflecting his appreciation of nature, mother nature and his spirituality. The paintings were amazing. He is considered one of the most famous in Bolivia today. Here is a wall of his work:
We also visited El Alto and saw a few cool locations. First was a trip to the Public University of El Alto, which student protests created. Seriously, they protested not having a school and one was created. We met students and did a mini-exchange. Sadly, we don’t live with them, but it was a great chance to meet some other students our age as we spend class with each other.
Then we went to El Trono, a theater that gets kids off the street in El Alto and teaches them theater, break dancing, allows them to go on a local radio station, etc. It’s fantastic. It was a beautiful building made of all recycled materials and many other start ups have emerged around Latin America. Plus, many children get to travel abroad to perform for international audiences. That was super amazing and something I’d really want to do. If it wasn’t for the whole… needing a real job thing. In fact, I realized here that I could have taken a totally other path in my life involving arts and reaching out to the community more so.
There was a volunteer from California that I realized I could really be/have been if I had not done the whole Econ major thing. I am also thinking recently on whether or not I would have liked that life more. Who knows, could just be cause I am here in the moment. But much of this class is tearing into the perfect theories of economics when put in practice. For example, the World Bank has so many concrete problems that we’ll get to later.
The group will be building a cool new village in Chapare (the coca region) that is essentially imagined and created by the kids. It is supposed to be a perfect village. They are putting things like composting toilets in and other sustainable items. It’s planned, but a fascinating idea. They have a wordpress blog to called “Pueblo De Los Creadores.” I may re-blog it at some point. It’s the type of place I’d go if I needed to just get the hell out of dodge for a bit to restart things.
Then the next day we did a bunch. We met the director of the movie Chiquiago, Antonio Eguino. It’s four vignettes of indigenous people in La Paz (the movie name, is the Aymara name for the city). It’s a beautiful film from 1978 that just truly captures the experience of Paceños from all socioeconomic backgrounds, focusing on the hardships of being indigenous. It’s a powerful film and I highly recommend watching it. The quality is not amazing, but that hardly changes the impact.
Then we met with World Bank officials in the French Alliance building. There we learned about the World Bank plans and people really went to town making this rep explain his points of view on development. I realized a few problems with the World Bank. They ignore politics. Completely. A democracy is any place without a coup. Also, development is monetary and formal sector based. There are many reasons for that, but it isn’t the end all. The rep did say that people don’t need to use the World Bank to develop. However, a government may not represent the views of the people just cause it didn’t have coups. In that sense, the World Bank has a failing. I don’t know, I was disturbed and don’t know if I could see myself doing that after this program. It’s funny, this rep is the only person whose name I missed as well… reflecting my slight disappointment.
I will add I thought people were a little unnecessarily vicious and unrealistic about what he’d say. Challenging his definition of development was a waste of time. He’s not going to change his mind publicly and hounding him on that point just wasted time I felt. It was more interesting to understand why the World Bank has not changed it’s definition or it ignores the political make-up beyond existence of coups. (Granted that probably isn’t official policy, but still it was a surprise.)
After that we went to Mujeres Creando. This is a group that promotes feminism and equality for women, as well as provides important services to them. They also graffiti their messages around the city (as I’m studying graffiti that was a great find). While they are a bit extreme and preachy, they do a lot of amazing work for women. Providing one of the few safe places for women in domestic violence situations and one of the few groups that just knows how to handle those issues correctly. While they are not likely to gain support with their extreme views, they are providing great services because they just do what they want. It’s a tradeoff.
A great quote by the speaker Julieta Paredes was:
“Some people ask if you are machista or feminist. That’s like asking if you are a robber or philosopher. That’s ridiculous.”
She had a point too and it addresses people’s confusion about the too. One is being a bad person who considers women lesser. The other is a philosophy, a way of viewing the world in which women are equal. The results of that equality may trouble people, but the two ideas are not even related.
The next day we went to Tocoli for the village stay. And holy crap what a beautiful place. We were right on Lake Titicaca. Like right there. And we got rowed out to look around and it was beautiful. Plus, the town was only 21 families and really tight-knit. Before you read “isolated” into my description, there was plenty of connection with the outside world. While this village was an old Aymara settlement that many of these families have lived in for a long time, they have radios, electricity, migrant workers and just in general contact with the outside world. They’re people. There are differences of course, but they are people.
Also, it was the first language barrier I encountered. Aymara was the only language of many of the women and that caused issues with communication. I have to admit though it was interesting to pick up what I could. Though it did trouble my Quechua.
Though I have to add I didn’t have an amazing time with my family. My host brother/dad (his mother was my mom, so it was a relationship I can only describe as such) spoke Spanish, but we didn’t really connect. The first night I was feeling a little off and not outgoing and that seemed to keep us from connecting from there on out. He also was only in town for the week on vacation from construction work in La Paz.
Additionally, my foot kept me from climbing the mountain. Actually, my foot made others keep me from climbing. I was a little tired on the way up to work with my brother/dad on construction and he told me to stop halfway up at a house of his friend, where Abby was homestaying. That was a fun day, she had six younger siblings I could play with. Plus, they let me help with the sheep which I couldn’t have done otherwise. Oh and her brother wrecked me at marbles. He was so good! Here’s a picture of her sister Viviana climbing me:
My brother wasn’t much of a talker either. He was in Aymara, but I found his Spanish hard to understand and he found mine hard to understand as well (neither of us spoke it as a first language). So we didn’t really bond. Plus, at the end pretty sure he didn’t know my name. Though I didn’t know my mother’s cause she only shared it once and I really had trouble pronouncing it. It was like Wanari or something. I felt weird using her first name though and as she never went further than a hundred feet from the house, I never saw her engage with other families. Seems kind of sad, but it is good that her many children (six) visit as often as they can.
Then I went down the mountain to eat and discovered Rene was staying up top and so I was free for the afternoon. I really had nothing to do. At all. So I went to the beach and hung out. Got a boat ride with my friend Ben’s dad. And watched them pick potatoes cause there weren’t enough tools to go round. Just ended up feeling disappointed sadly.
Making matters worse was the perpetual stomachache. I found myself unable to digest the potatoes. That was made clear once they came out the other end. That left me feeling disgusting and for some reason I was fed so much. So much! I just felt my stomach ready to blow at times and that left it so upset that talking and connecting was even harder. It also kept me from going out in the morning to see the sunrise on the Lake, which I had really looked forward to. I kind of saw it one morning from my house, but it just wasn’t the same I’m sure. I did get many amazing photos, but still always gonna regret that.
I did enjoy one food though. It’s called Pito and has the consistency of sawdust, but it’s a fine cornmeal. You need water or tea to eat it, but once I figured that out (such that it stopped sticking to the roof of my mouth) it was like a delicious cereal. I am going to see if I can find it elsewhere.
One upside were the cute animals. First was the beach puppy Charlie (I named him!). He was some sort of beautiful mixed breed that was super friendly. I usually don’t touch dogs, but he was too weak to bite (so no rabies) and I knew that it was too cold for many dangerous insects. So I played with plenty. Plus, the group loved him.
Also, my family’s cat (they also had hens) had three kittens while I was there. When I left they had 36 hours and could fit in the palm of your hand incredibly. That was amazing. They were so gosh darn cute.
Still, at the end I just was ready to leave. Our community work day was lackluster because of the classic behind schedule Bolivian Standard Time. So we started at 10:00 and were done by 12:30. We were supposed to dig a whole to gather water so they could make adobe bricks. The intention is to build an area where volunteers can stay when they visit. It was built on sacred ground, so it was cool to see them ask permission to build of the Pachamama (mother earth). Still the lack of work sucked. I wanted to help. Though I really blame our time constraints. If we had had another day it might have been possible to do more. I don’t know, just a thought.
Like I said I was ready to leave and enjoyed the ride in the bus. The landscape is beautiful in the Altiplano. Mountainous with long stretches of valleys and plain areas. Plus, it meant I could get non-potato food.
So… in sum… I was bummed about the village stay. I expected much more, but injury, sickness and a less than stellar family held me back from an amazing experience. It’s alright though. I did learn a bunch and am writing a reciprocity project children’s book about beach activities told from Charlie the dog’s point of view.
Oh here is a great shot on the lake.
Update: I may have been a little too negative about Vivir Bien. It’s a fantastic idea and I really want it to work. Though at times they are a bit too critical of economic theory. (Competition works and does find the optimal point. I do believe that. Issues arise when the assumptions don’t match the world, which is always and why competition often appears to suck.) Overall, Vivir Bien is cool. It tries to take into account externalities and that’s somewhere our system fails.
I also would love for it to work in the USA. And I think on an individual level it can. Even on a community level. But on a national level, it just won’t fly til we implement some structural changes. It’s really progressive. Plus, it’s some Bolivian program brought to the US? Many people are way too proud to take some “poor, backwards Latin American country’s system” in the world I see.
However, individuals can start to live this way. I know many who already do. I plan to do so more in the future. But as an official policy, not enough politicians will do this. They’d get kicked out. Maybe in the future it will change. I have a more progressive generation, I think. And I hope it will.
Thanks to my mother for pointing this out that I came off a little negative. I was trying to be realistic and it read as shutting down the plan. Still I have to be honest about my point of view. Please comment if you disagree and convince me otherwise, I’d like to be convinced otherwise.